Showing posts with label crime. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crime. Show all posts

Thursday, December 22, 2011

The Best Moment of 2011

The scandal that brought the most vicious media thugs to their knees.

The notion that nature will eventually run its course, even when it comes to the humbling of the most brutal bullies, came to a belated realisation with the News of the World scandal.

What a picture, to see that particular brand of vicious, foamin-at-the-mouth, self-righteous faux-moralistic fury turning on its own creators.

The succession of the nastiest bullies in the British media tumbling like sacks of rubbish in a garbage truck was just amazing: the arrest of Andy Coulson, the fall of Rebekah Brooks, News Corp withdrawing its BSkyB bid, and finally the News of the World going to the wall, while the two Murdoch thugs pathetically feigned amnesia in the background.

The phone-hacking scandal was just waiting to happen. When somebody's power to bully and intimidate with such impunity is allowed to fester to such poisonous proportions, it's just a matter of time til the putrefying boil bursts.

No doubt soon things will settle and hordes of dimwits are already stuffing their gob with the notion that tabloid thuggery (ie the indiscriminate phone hacking of murdered children, dead soldiers and grieving relatives) is none other than "free press".

But for a moment, just a moment, it was nice to see journalism in the UK back to a version of itself that doesn't resemble a cross between Shaun of the Dead and The Wicker Man.

Sunday, January 09, 2011

The hysterical reaction to Jack Straw's words

The left's own version of tabloid hysteria?

It says something when you have to think 150 times before writing a blog post because you fear your words may be misinterpreted and land you into trouble.

By now, you will be probably aware of the stir caused by Jack Straw's words in the wake of the recent conviction of a gang of nine men for the vile grooming and raping of 26 teenage girls.

In particular, the former Home Secretary was criticised for saying that there is a "specific problem which involves Pakistani heritage men... who target vulnerable young white girls" and that "[W]e need to get the Pakistani community to think much more clearly about why this is going on and to be more open about the problems that are leading to a number of Pakistani heritage men thinking it is OK to target white girls in this way".

The Labour MP for Blackburn added that: "These young men are in a western society, in any event, they act like any other young men, they're fizzing and popping with testosterone, they want some outlet for that, but Pakistani heritage girls are off-limits and they are expected to marry a Pakistani girl from Pakistan, typically. So they then seek other avenues and they see these young women, white girls who are vulnerable, some of them in care... who they think are easy meat".

Now, I'm hardly Straw's biggest fan, but I find some of the reactions to his comments verging on the manic, and it's a shame as they all come from some of my most favourite bloggers: from accusations of "Nazi racial profiling" and "smearing ALL pakistani men" on Liberal Conspiracy to the baffling "Jack Straw's sex fantasy about dark men and white girls" by Madam Miaow, "Jack Straw's scaremongering" on Pickled Politics and "generating double standards" by Chris Dillow on Stumbling and Mumbling.

So here's some thoughts on the issue:

1. Hysteria

Bear in mind that Straw was particularly careful to also say that "Pakistanis, let's be clear, are not the only people who commit sexual offences", adding that "overwhelmingly the sex offenders' wings of prisons are full of white sex offenders".

He shouldn't have bothered. He got likened to a Nazi before you could even utter the word.

This is the disturbing aspect. No matter the disclaimers, the specifications and the carefully weighed words. The same people who, on the left, rightly criticise the tabloid press for whipping up hysteria and frothing at the mouth, are guilty of the same knee-jerkism and are quite happy to throw cries of "RACIST!" and "NAZI!" and "DEHUMANISING PAKISTANI MALES!" at the drop of a hat.

2. Religion and culture, not race or nationality

Jack Straw made one mistake. He was too restrictive with his reference to the word "Pakistani". Religion here matters way more than a specific national heritage.

And, in fact, the chief executive of charity Barnardo's implied it when he said that "[his] staff would say there is an over-representation of people from ethnic minority groups among perpetrators - Afghans, people from Arabic nations, Pakistanis. But it's not just one nation".

Race and the colour of the skin has got absolutely nothing to do with it. Sure, there will always be some racist dunce trying to exploit the issue to make up for their lack of brain cells.

But it would be criminal if we let them deflect the core problem (and that's where too many people on the left go postal the moment you even mention it): the culture of misogyny that is rife amongst certain Muslim communities.

It is a deeply-ingrained culture of misogyny, and nothing else, that still allows the scandal of an estimated 17,000 women a year who are victims of honour crimes, including murder. It is a deeply-ingraned culture of misogyny that makes it possible, according to government figures, for 300 school children a year to disappear for the sake of forced marriages. It is misogyny and its ideology of oppression that makes it possible "to force young girls – some so young that they are still in push chairs", in the words of Yasmin Alibhai Brown – "[to be] covered up in hijabs". And that's just in the UK.

But who will speak out for them if simply raising the issue will land you accusations of "tarring all Muslim men with the same brush" and "the Ku Klux Klan [too] lynched black men in the Deep South"?

Like Johann Hari wrote two years ago, "[I]nsulating a religion from criticism – surrounding it with an electric fence called "respect" – keeps it stunted at its most infantile and fundamentalist stage. The smart, questioning and instinctively moral Muslims – the majority – learn to be silent, or are shunned (at best). What would Christianity be like today if George Eliot, Mark Twain and Bertrand Russell had all been pulped? Take the most revolting rural Alabama church, and metastasise it."

3. Red herrings and whataboutery

I find it deeply counterproductive when bloggers like Chris Dillow, someone I've always admired and respected, feel the need to write: "You wouldn’t ask the “white community” to look into itself if a white guy commits a sex crime, so why ask the “Pakistani community” to do so if a Pakistani does so".

I don't know why Dillow decides to drag "colour" into the debate, so let's just focus on his actual statement. Now, since no comparison is possible between "white" and "Pakistani" (white being a "race" encompassing anybody from Moldova to Iceland and "Pakistani" being a nationality), let's stick to the words "English community" or "British community" to see if they are ever "asked to look into themselves" in the face of problems or specific crimes.

The answer is yes. Older readers may recall the humongous debates and soul-searching that took place at the height of football hooliganism across the 1980s and 1990s.

There were literally thousands of political statements, opinion columns and sociological analyses written to dissect what was being dubbed "the English disease" and the term is still used to these days whenever UK football supporters behave like troglodites (see this and this, for instance).

Of course you do get some people shouting that "it's not just the English!" and "what about the football violence that also takes place in Holland, Italy and Turkey?", but most people understand that exercises in whataboutery and hyperbole will do little good.

Or take the tons of analyses written on the "British drinking too much", or what the government dubbed "the distinctive characteristic of the British drinking culture", its violence and aggression.

So, yeah, "the English" or "the British" have been asked to do some soul searching when it comes to certain problems. And rightly so. Bring it on. If there is a specific problem that is prevalent within your own society or community, what good does it do if you just drown it out with cries that "it's not just us!" and "AAAAARRRGH!". If you really cared about your own "community", why would you make "it also happens elsewhere" and "talk to the hand" the core of your argument?

As a person of Italian heritage, if there's one thing I find most grating is Italy's persistent shying away from an honest analysis of the Mafia on the grounds that it "hurts Italy's image" and "it doesn't do Italy any favours" and "not all Italians are in the Mafia".

And you don't need a degree in sociology and criminology to conclude that the biggest beneficiaries of sweeping cultural problems under the carpet are the perpetrators of said problems.

4. The actual issue

Dillow is right to produce the hard figures about sexual offences (for instance the fact that in Lancashire "4.163 per 10,000 white Brits were arrested for a sex crime, compared to 0.44 Pakistanis"). Once again, Straw said it himself that "overwhelmingly the sex offenders' wings of prisons are full of white sex offenders".

However, Straw also referred to the specific issue of gangs grooming teenage girls for sex. And, in that case, out of 17 cases since 1997, 50 out of the 56 men convicted were Pakistani Muslims.

It was Manzoor Moghul, chairman of the Muslim Forum who said that "Offenders are under the misapprehension white girls are easy prey. The way they dress, their culture, makes them easy pickings". And it was Mohammed Shafiq, chief executive of the Ramadhan Foundation, a Muslim youth organisation, who said to the BBC that "[t]here are some Muslims who think that as long as these sex gangs aren't targeting their own sisters and daughters the issue doesn't affect them" (see here).

Not regarding girls from different religious or ethnic groups with the same respect granted to their own sisters or mothers is a vile practice. It is not racist to say so.

Sunday, January 02, 2011

The public mauling of Chris Jefferies

How the concept of "innocent until proven guilty", one of the pillars of British democracy, is being butchered by the tabloid press.

By now you're all probably familiar with the fresh display of tabloid barbarism seen in the wake of the tragic murder of Jo Yeates.

In brief, in the 72 hours that sandwiched the arrest and then the release of suspect Chris Jefferies in connection with the murder, the media handed him some diabolical public guillotine for the sake of a few extra banknotes basted in lynchmob froth.

No-one, not even the police, knows whether Mr Jefferies has anything to do, or not, with the murder. In fact, no-one will know until a trial takes place.

But the fact that Mr Jefferies hasn't even been charged yet seems to have completely eluded the tabloids. They've already passed their verdict, dishing all the dirt they could dig up in order to destroy him.

The news massacre has been so mental and OTT that even Attorney General Dominic Grieve went on record expressing his concerns that the current coverage of the Jo Yeates murder may be in breach of the Contempt of Court Act as well as an impediment to the ongoing legal proceedings.

The following articles are a fine analysis of the public mauling of Chris Jefferies:

Mark Thompson ("The media need to stop these witchhunts") focuses on the astonishing collection of what he dubs "ridiculous nudge-nudge, wink-wink comments" and generally anything that will make Chris Jefferies look as weird as possible.

Jerry Hayes ("The hounding of Christopher Jeffries and anyone who is different") makes the excellent point that
"[i]f [Mr Jefferies] is charged, British Justice assures him of a fair trial. But if he is not charged or acquitted, his life will never be the same again. He will be regarded as that strange, eccentric, blue rinsed loner, somehow connected with a death".

Finally, Enemies of Reason ("Chris Jefferies and trial by media") draws parallels with the character assassination and [the] targeting aspects of people's private lives" as already seen in "the trials by media undergone by Colin Stagg, Robert Murat, Barry George, the parents of Madeleine McCann and the first man to be accused of the Ipswich murders of 2006 (who was leater released without charge)".

Friday, December 10, 2010

Reflections on yesterday's riots

All violence is wrong, right?

1) The attack on Prince Charles and Camilla's car.
I understand it's a massive media story and I don't think anyone can remember within living memory an instance of a British royal coming under some form of attack. But excuse me if I spare my outrage for the stories of totally innocent demonstrators being battered by the police (click here for a collection of stories about what the police did yesterday). Why should an egg on Prince Charles' car matter more than an innocent 20 year old bleeding on the brain?

2) The media focus.
Obviously it's daft to expect the same tabloids who for weeks defended the indefensible in the wake of Ian Tomlinson's murder to manage even a sprinkling of objectivity when reporting yesterday's events.
But it's amazing that while the Sun shouts "How dare these thugs insult the country" and the Daily Mail makes it top news that Camilla was prodded in the ribs (though the headline says "HIT", of course), hardly a mention is made that 43 students were taken to hospital (some extremely serious) and that thousands of people were kettled for 6+ hours before any violence started.

3) Kettling.
Which begs the question. What possible good can come from kettling for more than 6 hours thousands of peaceful demonstrators in freezing temperatures - and that's before any violence had kicked off? How can anyone in their right mind think that this is not going to pour petrol on the flames?
Remember that kettling means being penned within a confined square, literally squeezed against hundreds of other people without any access to food, water or toilets and not knowing when the police is going to grant mercy.

4) Violence is wrong.
And that's all violence, both policemen battering students already lying on the pavement and excitable demonstrators vandalising public property and damaging the students' cause. Thanks to them, yesterday's vote in the Commons is now totally overshadowed.

Wednesday, December 08, 2010

Squalid little irony

While Sarah "Issues" Palin calls for Assange to be "hunted down like an Al-Quaeda terrorist", take a look at those two excellent analyses of the growing Wikileaks controversy.

This is Johann Hari in today's Independent:

"There is a squalid little irony when you see people who are literally bombing innocent civilians every day feverishly accuse a man who has never touched a weapon in his life of being “covered in blood.” Wikileaks have hurt nobody. They redacted sensitive names. They held back any cables that could expose anyone to risk. They asked the Pentagon to help them by privately explaining where they believed there could be a danger – only to be rebuffed".

And this is one of Hagley Road's favourite bloggers, Justin McKeating:

"Let’s be blunt. The face of Wikileaks, Julian Assange, is a massive honking idiot. He’s made a series of classic errors. The first was not in getting himself diplomatic immunity…[...]Another mistake was failing to get himself accused of war crimes. Then he could have come and gone from the UK as he pleased. If only he led a racist organisation like the Ku Klux Klan, his website would still be able to accept credit card donations."

Tuesday, December 07, 2010

On Julian Assange

If the tons of information that are being put online are "little more than a mish-mash of gossip and rumours" (Littlejohn, Daily Mail), "a storm in a teacup" (The Corner Pub), "ridiculous" (the Russian government), "a collection of little substance" (Benedict Brogan, the Telegraph), or even "WikiYawn" (Michael Peck), why then is Julian Assange suddenly the most wanted man in the world, international arrest warrant and all?

UPDATE (12:02pm)- "Wikileaks founder Julian Assange arrested in London" (BBC News).

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Tory Libertarians, where are ye?

A blog giving advice to demonstrators from student fees protest is shut down by the police without a court order.

We happen to think that, if only the violent minority had stayed in and sipped a nice mug of camomile instead of seeking attention and chucking fire extinguishers at last Wednesday's London student protest, the debate over the Coalition's trebling of tuition fees would actually still be focused on exactly it: the trebling of tuition fees.

But whatever your thoughts on the demo, it emerged today that the police shut down a blog called FitWatch for the simple reason that they offered a number of tips on students fearing arrest in the wake of the demonstration.

The police reckoned that advice ranging from "don't panic" and "do get rid of your clothes" to "don't hand yourself in" and "do get the name of a good lawyer" was tantamount to "attempt to pervert the course of justice", telling the host (JustHost) to suspend the site. The worrying bit is that they did so without a court order.

I wonder where the Tory Libertarians and assorted "defenders of free speech" are. Let us know if and when you hear a knock.

More on the subject here.

Wednesday, July 07, 2010

In memory of 7/7


Five years ago, already. This same morning in 2005, four suicide bombers committed one of the vilest, most ruthless, most disgusting atrocities in British history. They hit London at its core and took the lives of 52 innocent people sitting on three underground trains and a double-decker bus. May they rest in peace.

Thursday, June 03, 2010

Cumbria shootings: who do you blame?

As usual with this type of crime, singling out patterns or invoking further legislation is pointless.

With Britain waking up to the worst firearms tragedy since Dunblane, the predictable finger-pointing begins.

And yet the police are still trying to piece the story together. It was unclear what exactly tipped 52-year-old Derrick Bird, the killer, over the edge. Was he having financial problems? Did he have a row with his fellow taxi drivers over queue-jumping and touting? Did he fall out with his relatives over a will? Did years of solitude and a broken marriage take their toll?

No-one will probably ever find out. The only certainty is that something made Bird lose the plot completely. Something flicked a switched that got him to embark on a deadly rampage, killing thirteen and injuring more in a mist of rage reminiscing of the worst horror films.

Derrick Bird was certainly angry and frustrated. But there are a lot of angry and frustrated people about. He was a bit of a loner. But luckily most quiet people don't usually pick up a gun and aim at random passers by.

Bird didn't fit the stereotypical Daily Mail and Sun profile of council-estate-dweller-turned-monster courtesy of New Labour and dole handouts and he wasn't, at least on the surface, a "victim of neo-liberalism" and the bankers' crisis either. He lived in a quiet town and he wasn't party to any rival gang.

The simple, terrifying, fact is that we can all suddenly lose it. Anyone, anytime. There is little point in trying to rationalise or establish visible patterns that would explain behaviour like the one seen yesterday in Cumbria.

Some commentators like Peter Squires in the Guardian wrote that better and stricter gun control "could have prevented [the] Cumbria shootings". And yet, without wishing for a second to play down the tragic nature of the events, this is only the third such incident in 23 years.

Like Richard Ford points out in the Times, both after Hungerford in 1987 and Dunblane ten years later, gun laws were significantly tightened with the Violent Crime Reduction Act of 2006 adding further restrictions.

Yes, 1.3 million shotguns in the UK are way too many. And, for the life of me, I can't think of anything good that's ever come out of gun-ownership and the intrinsic machism that come with it (incidentally, why is it always men who are responsible for mass shootings?). I agree that no guns would mean no gun violence and that knives, slingshots and baseball bats, however dangerous, can't be compared in terms of deadliness.

Yet -let's keep it within perspective and say something positive for once- 3 appalling incidents in 23 years from a total of 1.3m shotguns in the country means that 0,0002% of firearms in Britain have resulted in an incident like the one seen yesterday.

There is no point in passing further legislation just to impress public opinion. No law can do anything when a person loses it like Derrick Bird did.

Thursday, May 06, 2010

A New Britain under the Tories?

The Lessons of History vs the Sun, Simon Cowell & Richard Littlejohn...

St Pauls, Bristol, 1980

Brixton, 1981

Toxteth, Liverpool, 1981

The Miners' strike, 1984

Handsworth, Birmingham, 1985

Brixton, 1985

Printers strike, Wapping, 1986-87

Strangeways Prison, Manchester, 1990

Poll Tax riots, London, 1990

May 6, 2010: Are you sure this is what you want?

Monday, March 01, 2010

On crime and detention centres

No time to write anything today, but here are two articles that I thoroughly recommend.

Neil at The Bleeding Heart Show highlights the national shame of Yarl's Wood detention centre, the privately run immigration detention fortress plc where several detainees are entering their fourth week of hunger strike in protest at ongoing abuse and general inhumane conditions.

Yesterday, I criticised the Cuban regime for allowing one of their prisoners to die after an 86-day hunger strike. I wonder if the Labour government are willing to avoid a similar catastrophe at home.

The second piece is by Chicken Yoghurt and it refers to Gordon Brown's speech on crime earlier today. The Prime Minister slammed the Tories and their tabloids for "cultivating a public sense of panic". But then he proceeded to do exactly the same as he bigged up New Labour’s policy on DNA database.

So basically, "don’t listen to Tory fear-mongering but pay close attention to Gordon’s".

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Some people are seriously appalling

Watching this programme on disability hate crime made me feel ashamed of being human. There is no way certain evil behaviour can be explained, let alone excused. Judge for yourself.

[Read more about subhuman scums starting on disabled people here]

Thursday, February 11, 2010

Fairness/unfairness

If you're after some cash, force your way into someone's home brandishing weapons and threatening rape and murder. Reast assured you will not go to jail.

(Contribution by Stan Moss)

Last year two "drink and drug fuelled yobs" broke into a house in Hull armed with a knuckle duster and a spade demanding money as they threatened to burn everything, rape the mother and then kill the whole family.

They then grabbed an ornamental sword and reiterated their threats.

The two then dropped the sword but continued with the death threats, at which point Mr Fullard (the homeowner) grabbed the weapon and sliced one of the intruders' ear off in self defence (see photo). He was arrested and, after a legal ordeal that lasted ten months, he was finally cleared.

The two armed scumbags (both with previous convictions) were given a 6-month suspended sentence (meaning that they won't spend a single minute behind bars) and 100 hours of community work, which they should complete within two weeks tops.

The moral of the story? If you're after some cash, force your way into someone's home. Feel free to brandish weapons and to threaten rape, arson and murder. Reast assured you will not go to jail.

-----
Just as a term of reference, in 2005 two young men caught spraying graffiti onto trains in Manchester were sentenced to 10 months' youth detention. They actually did time. The judge said "he hoped it would deter others".

Also in 2005, a 73-year-old OAP from Exeter was sentenced to prison for refusing to pay an outstanding council tax bill of £53.71. A 71-year-old from Northamptonshire was jailed for 28 days for a similar offence.

The reader can decide whether the justice system in Britain is fucked up or not.

Saturday, January 30, 2010

I maintain, the double standards are vile

When a crime is a crime and NOT an item for politicking. If only every family-related crime was reported in the same fashion, regardless of the perpetrator's income.

In the last few days I wrote two posts (see here and here) about the neurotic double standards adopted by the British media and politicians in relation to crime. When my remarks were republished (though heavily edited) on Liberal Conspiracy, certain commenters went simply apeshit.

"Pretty fucking poor taste" and "the piece reads as if Claude is sneering at these tragedies" remarked someone. "Moir-esque", quipped someone else. "How low can you go?" was another comment and so on.

I didn't have a chance to reply, so let's take a look.

How the fuck did I "sneer at these tragedies"? How dare you? If there's anything I'm sneering at that's the patronising tone that millions of people under a certain income have to endure each and every single time a crime or a tragedy takes place amongst the least affluent.

I'm raising an eyebrow at the relentless tabloid barrage about the usual roll call of "broken society", "scumbags", "evil social workers" and "Labour bankrolling the feckless". The opinion columns slamming "welfare layabouts" (see here) or calling for the state "to curtail the rights of everyone to have children" (see this or this). The condescending inches of columns spewing out that "[T]he working class of the past had enormous self-respect [because] men, however poor, wore suits and ties" (click here, if you don't believe it).

I'm sneering at the lectures from vulture-like politicians preying about for political pointscoring, like Tory MP Iain Duncan Smith when he dubbed a report from his own Centre for Social Cohesion "timely" because it came out straight after the Baby P scandal. Or when, only last week, David Cameron felt the need to relate the brutal Edlington tortures to "Labour's moral failure".

As for "Moir-esque", the chap who wrote the remark needs to look up the word "analogy" in the dictionary. Because he may as well have compared my post to an hamburger or a Gary Neville own goal.

Moir did a vile, homophobic hatchet job on an innocent dead man. On the converse, I demanded respect for the dead, regardless of their family background. The aim of my post was to express frustration at seeing the most tragic of circumstances used as a fig leaf for class snobbery of the lowest kind- the type of sniping where even a family tragedy or a brutal murder is used to sneer at an entire class of people or to promote social engineering and cuts on the welfare state.

If you can't grasp the humongous double standards from both media and politicians alike, then I feel sorry for you. The evidence is so obvious that it's ridiculous.

The case of Fiona Donnison, the wealthy City woman charged with asphyxiating her children to death, has been reported the way such a chilling case should be treated: like a crime. A cruel, irrational, devastating one, with aggravating factors or mitigating circumstances - but a crime nonetheless and not an item for politicking.

Simply, many wish every family-related crime was reported in the same fashion, regardless of the perpetrator's income.

To wrap it up, I quote the spot-on words of a commenter called Jim.
"Whatever happens [Fiona Donnison]’s lifestyle will never be put under the microscope they way, say, Shannon Mathews’ mother’s life was. The poor on sink estates are never ‘under pressure’ or their life never ‘falls apart’. There is never any mitigation for a ‘home alone’ family that crop up.

We will never see the forensic unpicking of the family life of this woman; we will never read in lurid detail how many lovers she had or any drug use she has indulged in, the motivation for having these kids or any trends established, because when the middle class go postal, nothing could have prevented it. There will be no ‘baby P’ column inches for these children, no vilification of social workers, no rows of photographers encamped outside the doors of this dysfunctional family
".

Friday, January 29, 2010

Save us all, Iain Duncan Smith

A child murderer who worked in the City had just split from her husband. If only the Tories had been in power to give'em a tax break.

Yesterday it emerged that a former city worker living in a £500,000 home in East Sussex may have killed her own two children aged 2 and 3. They were found locked in the back of her Nissan and the post-mortem said they asphyxiated.

But the main point is this. According to the Daily Mail, Mrs Donnison and her husband had just split up. In fact, "the couple's marriage had been falling apart for a long time", adding extra strains on the woman.

No doubt if Iain Duncan Smith's tax break for married couples had been already in place the two would still be together. Under the Tories' proposals, with children under 3 the Donnisons would have been entitled to a tax allowance. And surely an extra twenty or thirty quid extra a month would have helped them patch their differences and nipped family arguments in the bud.

****
Like we wrote the other day about a similarly disturbing case, Fiona Donnison's child murders won't spark any national debate about Broken Britain, Labour's social engineering, lazy council estate dwellers or even the decline of coal mining: the killer was (very) wealthy so she simply snapped, that's all.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Crime on a council estate? Ten times as bad

While the Edlington case sparked a national debate on "Broken Britain", a trial about a beastly murder took place elsewhere. You didn't hear about it because it didn't happen on a council estate.

You already know that last weekend newspapers were full of news and analyses about the Edlington brothers' trial and their brutal actions.

But exactly at the same time, a court case went on about a merciless, sadistic murder that took place in a "neat" and "respectable" privately rented terraced home in the town of Chilton, Co Durham. With the exception of some sporadically recycled wire copy, a piece in the Mirror and the local press, nationwide the case went largely unnoticed.

And yet it was the prefect tabloid material, a case so shocking that it would not be out of place in a horror movie script. In fact, it bears disturbing similarities with the tragic story of Sylvia Likens (later the subject of the film An American Crime). It was a killing so savage, cruel and calculated that the DCI leading the investigation said he "had never seen anything like it" in his lengthy police career.

The details of the case are disturbing. When 35-year-old Andrew Gardner died, his girlfriend Clare Nicholls told the police he'd been assaulted by muggers while on his way home. Yet, the details that emerged painted a radically different picture. Andrew had not left home for months. During that time, he'd been meticulously tortured and gradually starved to death by Clare, along with her ex-lover and her brother.

The postmortem showed the victim had "150 injuries including 21 rib fractures, a broken skull and brain injuries so severe they were like those suffered in a car crash or fall from a tall building". The torture took place in front of Andrew and Clare's own daughter and the woman's other three children who were even encouraged to take part in the assaults "because they thought it was normal". At one stage a noughts and crosses game was carved into the skin on the victim's back.

In the end, Ms Nicholls was sentenced to 32 years in jail and her brother to 25 years. This was a case that would grant an entire conference on psychopathic and murderous behaviour and the press hardly blinked.

Rest assured, however, that if the murderer hadn't lived in a nice privately-rented house, didn't have "a pristine public image" and hadn't helped at the local charity shop, the papers would now be oozing headlines such as "MOTHER OF PURE EVIL", "LAZY SEX MAD WITH A RING FROM ARGOS SYMBOLISES BROKEN BRITAIN" and "MURDERS WILL KEEP HAPPENING IF WE KEEP BANKROLLING THE UNDERCLASS".

The double standards are just amazing.

Saturday, January 23, 2010

Can evil always be explained?

It is perfectly normal that we try to explain a crime or an act of evil. But the obsessive, opportunistic search for scapegoats often verges on the pathetic.

With the shocking case of the Edlington attacks coming to court, I've lost count of the number of hacks and politicians explaining what turned those two children into "monsters".

David Cameron was quick at pointing the finger at "Broken Britain" and all that is "going deeply wrong" in society under Labour, words that anyone with half a brain would associate with the most distasteful cheap political pointscoring. As if no heinous crime took place when Maggie and Major were in government in the 80s and 90s - something so obvious that it's actually painful to type up.

To be fair, Robert Reiner is even more pathetic. In his view, the fault lies with "the key aspects of neo-liberalism", he writes in today's Guardian, adding that "the embrace of unfettered free-market economics by [Cameron's] party in the 1980s and by their buddies around the world" is to blame. Wasn't there anyone at hand to tell this man that the Moors Murders took place in the early 1960s?

David Wilson follows similar lines. "Boy torturers were already tortured", is the headline to his article in the Guardian. He insists that the two torturers already experienced a background lined with neglect, that they were even allowed to watch porn or gory films like Saw and that they often witnessed their aggressive father in action. All ingredients that would make 3/4 of the UK population potential "monsters" then.

Along the same lines, left and right, the roll call of social services and children boards, blood-spattered movies and porn on tap, Labour's Britain and Thatcher's neo-liberalism, the death of the coal industry and state benefits, narcissism and the underclasses.

However, what if -for once- we stopped our finger pointing and quit digging up explanations at all costs?
Can pure evil always be explained? Could it be that the responsibility lies solely with the perpetrator and that the irrational, inexplicable evil streak that runs through humankind sometimes cannot be deciphered?

Because unfortunately, torturers, serial killers and assorted scumbags have stemmed from all decades and walks of life, pre- and post-Thatcherism, pre- and post-New Labour, in council estates and in more affluent homes, the product of a "broken family" or an apparently solid one. They may have watched horror films or not. They may have been into classical music or Marilyn Manson.

John George Haigh, the "Acid Bath Murderer" wasn't on state benefits, didn't smoke spliffs and didn't have the opportunity to watch Saw as a child. He was brought up a devout Christian and even went to a grammar school. Alas, that didn't stop him from dissolving nine people in acid.

Fred West may have come from a poor family of farm workers with a terrifying history of incest and bestiality, but Harold Shipman was brought up in an apparently stable and religious house, completed his studies and remained a respected and well-paid GP until someone found out he murdered up to 250 people for no apparent reason.

Baby P was tortured and abused by a crack cocaine addict and a sadistic neo Nazi in a manky council flat, but six innocent people were chopped up by Dennis Nilsen, a soldier, then a policeman and then a civil servant in middle-class Muswell Hill.

Some people may argue that he was a loner though, which may have given the game away, but then look at Peter Sutcliffe. His social life was apparently "normal", he had mates, but still he became known as the Yorkshire Ripper.

Mary Bell, convicted of the manslaughter of two boys in 1968, was the daughter of a prostitute and an unknown father. Steve Gerald Wright though, known as the Suffolk Strangler, came from a middle-class family and later became a pub landlord.

So to Daily Mail readers, Thatcher-haters, political opportunists and all the devil's advocates crying out for mitigating circumstances: stop trying to single out water-tight and predictable patterns of psychopathy. Shovelling blame onto others will do no good. As loath as I am to admit it, some people are simply beyond help.

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Why banning Islam4UK is a very good thing

Democracy does not mean that you can call for the stoning of all homosexuals or the massacre of those who insult Islam.

Isn't it touching to see the chiefs of Islam4UK , the same people who once famously held placards that read "FREEDOM GO TO HELL", whingeing and moaning that "freedom is turning into a dictatorship" on the day the government finally decided to ban them?

Isn't it stunning to savour the contradictions of a man, Anjem Choudary, who calls for a fundamentalist Muslim regime in Britain where every single citizen should convert to his particular brand of Islam, while at the same time crying for his "freedom of expression"?

Isn't it pathetic to read that "Muslims merely stand up and say that we are being oppressed, that our brothers and sisters are being murdered", while not a word is ever said about the thousands of Muslim brothers and sisters who are butchered every month in the name of Islam in Pakistan, Afghanistan and other countries (see this)?

True, in theory the ban on Islam4UK and its sister organisations al-Muhajiroun and al-Ghurabaa may be a bad day for freedom of speech.

But their track record is just intolerable. Democracy does not mean that you can demonstrate in central London waving banners such as "Massacre those who insult Islam", "Be prepared for the real holocaust" and "the Fantastic 4 are on their way". You can't call a press conference and call for the "stoning of all homosexuals" without facing the consequences.

Anjem Choudary, current leader of Islam4UK, is the same man who went on BBC Hardtalk (and shame on those who invited him) and said that the victims of the 7/7 atrocity were fair game because "only the Muslims are innocent" and if you don't accept Islam "that is a crime against God". He refused to condemn the London bombings, called the 9/11 attack "magnificent", publicly remarked that "Islam is not a religion of peace" and said that "the Pope should face capital punishment".

A year ago, his mentor Omar Bakri, now in Lebanon, said at a public meeting "Do not obey the British law" and "we must fight and die for Islam".

If all of the above (and that's just a brief summary) isn't incitement to hatred, violence and terrorism, than what is? How can normally commendable bloggers such as A Very Public Sociologist write that "[Islam4UK] do not intimidate their opponents" and that the ban is "indefensible"?

Even the idea that the ban may "force some people underground" is ill-informed. To start with, you have to balance it out with the effect that Islam4UK's ultra-inflammatory activities can have on community cohesion and the stirring up of tension and violence.

Second, one assumes that security forces would be keeping an eye on those groups anyway, the only notable change being that their odious public glorification of terrorism and abuse against sexual minorities and other religions (which is illegal) will have to stop.

The fact that Islam4UK isn't a "white" or "christian" brand of nazism does not make it any less dangerous. To quote journalist Johann Hari, "the real racism would be to hold non-white people to lower standards, as if their bigotries were less real or less deadly".

Monday, January 04, 2010

Terrorism

Could it be that we're giving the mass-murdering fundamentalists just what they want?

Forget my naiveté but something doesn't quite add up over the security panic that followed last week's failed terror attempt to blow up a transatlantic airliner.

Britain has joined the US and other countries in toughening up checks at airports. Full body scanners, hand luggage checks and no toilet access an hour before landing are amongst some of the measures introduced to tame the new wave of psychosis that is hitting the western world.

Now. Let's say that your house was broken into once and, hypothetically, you decided to take extra security measures to protect it. Iron bars on the bedroom window, armoured glass fitted with welded steel hinges, a special 24/7 CCTV guarding the room and a 10st stainless steel padlock to round it all off, are all concrete measures that would set your mind at rest.

However, with the initial excitement out of the way comes the realisation that all of the above may just be an expensively futile exercise. The bedroom may be safer than a fortress, but front door, living room, kitchen and all other entry points are as vulnerable as they were before.

Similarly, one wonders whether the current security theatre is being a little bit crook-eyed. You may now have to have your anus x-rayed if you're boarding a flight, but absolutely anything and anyone is free to stroll on and off any train or hop around the tube network (in London alone there's a daily ridership of around 3 million people).

Just look at the records. Sure, the last ten years have seen the bloodiest most traumatic terror attack ever (9/11) alongside a couple of well-publicised attempts coming from the sky (the 'shoe bomber' as well as the 2006 Walthamstow plot).

Sadly, however, there's also been a painful record of terror attacks on metros, buses and trains (Madrid 2004 and London 2005- plus failed attempts) as well as explosions against specifically targeted buildings (i.e. Casablanca in 2003 and Bali twice, in 2002 and 2005).

There's also a second point. I'm not for a second belittling the scale of what that spoilt fanatical dickhead was doing onboard the Amsterdam-Detroit flight last week. But, bearing in mind that terrorists want to achieve hysteria, panic and mayhem of the largest possible scale, hasn't the press at large handed it to Al-Quaeda on a tray?

Press blackouts were tried in the past, both in the fight against terrorism in Northern Ireland and at the height of the RAF and Red Brigades' campaigns in Germany and Italy respectively.

What if governments and security forces around the world set up a concerted plan not to give Al-Quaeda the oxygen of publicity, unless of course there were damage and casualties to report?

Wouldn't the blackout deal at least a partial blow to the campaign of fear and hatred that the Islamic funda-mentalists have been inflicting upon the world?

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Daily Mail cheers death penalty in China

In a world ruled by the Daily Mail they'd run out of hangmen in no time at all.

Leo McKinstry, normally busy penning armchair warrior articles for the Express or anti gay ramblings in the Sun, is today arguing in the Daily Mail ('Sorry not to join the liberal wailing: heroin traffickers deserve to die') that China's execution by lethal injection of British citizen Akmal Shaikh is a welcome thing.

The background is that Mr Shaikh was guilty of smuggling 4kgs of heroine into Urumqi, north-west China in 2007. The man was reportedly mentally-ill. His daughter said that "drug smugglers in Poland convinced him they would make him a pop star in China" and Gordon Brown tried in vain to talk the Chinese Prime Minister into a last minute reprieve.

It's the first time since the 1950s that a European citizen is executed in China.

According to the Daily Mail article, however, people who opposed China's decision are "the trendy metropolitan elite, for whom drug use is a fashionable habit rather than serious criminal offence". McKinstry slams it as an "orchestrated wailing" from the "human rights brigade and celebrity loudmouths".

His sophisticated analysis includes this gem: "Unlike China with its firing squads, the only 'shooting galleries' we have in Britain are state-run needle exchanges for junkies". For good measure, the article also sports a photo of Kate Moss with the caption "a country that revers such junkies as Kate Moss has no right to lecture China on its drug policy".

Now, the Daily Mail has recently expressed extreme disdain for a wide range of categories: childless women, asylum seekers, immigrants, bankers, benefit recipients, BBC staff, social workers, NHS managers, teachers, politicians, liberals, Muslims, homosexuals, dogs, fat people, anorexic people, council tenants etc...But this is the first time they're openly calling for firing squads to show 'junkies' how it's done.

"The drug-fuelled, crime-ridden, welfare-dependent, fear-filled inner city housing estate in modern Britain is far more savage than any place of execution in China for a trafficker of human misery", adds McKinstry.

Of course it would be too easy to argue that perhaps McKinstry and his like should just fuck off to China and have more than one child in an urban area and see what happens, especially if they also happen to carry around a Bible, a free-Tibet poster, a copy of Zoo, or simply check the internet, Wikipedia or Facebook.

But we won't. Let's just say instead, that a world that is ruled by Daily Mail standards would possibly have a handful of people left within years. With everyone else exterminated (much to the chagrin of the "human rights brigade", of course), they would run out of hangmen in no time at all.

See this for a comprehensive analysis of capital punishment in the UK.